Translate

The Caliphs’ Harem and the Shadow of the Ghilmān: A History of Non-Normative Sexualities in the Lands of Islam (article)

.


.
The Caliphs’ Harem and the Shadow of the Ghilmān: A History of Non-Normative Sexualities in the Lands of Islam




The idea that Muslim societies have always been uniformly hostile to every form of non-procreative sexuality is a recent construction, largely inherited from colonial puritanism and the religious reformisms of the nineteenth century. An examination of the historical, literary, and juridical sources produced between the eighth and eighteenth centuries reveals an infinitely more complex reality, made up of de facto tolerance, codified institutions, and accepted contradictions. From the streets of Baghdad under the Abbasids to the Safavid courts of Isfahan, by way of the palaces of Cordoba and the Ottoman harems, homosexual practices, lesbian practices, and non-binary gender expressions not only existed but were structuring components of social, artistic, and political life, often far removed from the theoretical condemnation of the jurists.

We must first return to the figure of the mukhannath, the “effeminate” man of the Medinan period, in order to understand that gender non-conformity was not an imported anomaly but a reality integrated from the very beginnings of Islam. The mukhannathūn were men whose behavior, gestures, and sometimes appearance differed from the masculine norm, without for all that being considered women. The hadiths report that some of them had free access to female spaces, precisely because they were perceived as devoid of heterosexual desire and therefore socially harmless to the modesty of the Prophet’s wives. This permeability of the boundaries of gender became institutionalized under the Umayyads and then under the Abbasids, when the mukhannathūn became indispensable musicians, singers, and court entertainers. Far from being marginalized, they occupied a recognized social function in the economy of pleasure and festivity, to such an extent that the caliph al-Saffah, the first of the Abbasids, had a half-brother, governor of Mosul, reputed for his immoderate taste for wine and the company of mukhannathūn. The court of Harun al-Rashid (r. 786–809) even saw their official rehabilitation after a period of censorship under the Umayyad caliphate of Sulayman in 717. This visibility was not without risk: if gender expression was tolerated, it became punishable when accompanied by an explicit sexual claim or a transgression of the codes of honor, which shows that the red line was not identity or desire in itself, but the disturbance of social order and of women’s reputation.

It was in this Abbasid soil that one of the most famous literary flowerings of love between men blossomed: the homoerotic poetry of Abu Nuwas. This court poet, a favorite of Harun al-Rashid and then of al-Amin, sang with astonishing freedom of the beauty of young cupbearers, the ghilmān, and of the pleasure of wine. His poems are not the stuff of shameful confession but of a fully assumed literary genre, mujūn (obscene and libertine poetry), which circulated in the most refined circles of Baghdad. The literature of the period does not content itself with mentioning these relations: it theorizes, aestheticizes, and celebrates them. The ghulāmiyyāt, those young girls disguised as boys or those boys with androgynous features, became central figures of poetry and court life. The caliph al-Amin himself, son of Harun al-Rashid, is described by the chroniclers as openly attracted to men; his father worried about it, not so much for moral reasons as for the political stability of his succession. The historians al-Tabari and Ibn al-Athir report that he bought eunuchs for his court, showed them particular affection, and spent entire nights in their company. This court homosexuality was not a shameful secret but a trait of the sovereign’s character that the chroniclers mention with disarming frankness, sometimes to criticize it, sometimes simply to describe it.

The harem, that space so often fantasized by orientalism as a place of purely heterosexual seclusion, was in reality a far more complex universe, structured by a hierarchy of genders and statuses. The eunuchs (khāṣī), castrated to serve in the private apartments, constituted an institutionalized “third gender,” a pre-Islamic status integrated into Islamic courts. Their castration made them, in theory, asexual and therefore fit to associate with the women of the harem without arousing the master’s jealousy. But the reality was more nuanced: eunuchs held considerable power, wove alliances, and some of them were described as objects of desire for the men of the court, creating a paradoxical “gender fluidity” within the very space supposed to be the most strictly gendered. The jawārī, the concubines, were female slaves whose bodies and sexuality belonged to their master. Their primary function was procreation and pleasure, but they were not for all that devoid of sexual agency. The medieval sources, notably the treatises of jurisprudence and the collections of anecdotes, discuss at length siḥāq (tribadism, or relations between women). The jurist al-Nuwayrī, in the fourteenth century, devotes an entire chapter to the subject, citing hadiths that compare it to zinā (fornication) and present it as a grave fault. Yet almost all the Sunni juridical schools agree that siḥāq does not constitute a crime of ḥadd (fixed penalty), unlike liwāṭ (male sodomy), because it does not involve penetration and does not threaten patrilineal filiation. This fundamental distinction between the male act, which risks “blurring” the lineage, and the female act, judged less dangerous for the social order, explains the relative indulgence of the jurists. The caliph al-Hadi, in the ninth century, nevertheless had two of his concubines beheaded after surprising them in an amorous relation, but the chroniclers themselves are indignant at this excessive severity, presenting it as proof of the sovereign’s excess and arbitrariness. The anecdote of al-Tifachi, in the thirteenth century, which stages a notable seeking to inquire into lesbian practices and being told that he need only return home without announcing himself, reveals above all male voyeurism and the blindness of husbands, far more than systematic repression.

The geography of these practices draws an archipelago of variable tolerances. In Umayyad Andalusia, intellectual and urban elites indulged without complexes in homosexual pleasures, and mujūn poetry flourished between the tenth and thirteenth centuries. The caliph al-Hakam II (r. 961–976) had no heir before the age of 46, which some historians attribute to his predilection for young boys (ḥubb al-ghulām), while others see in it simply the disinterest of a sovereign more absorbed by his books than by the pleasures of the flesh. In Mamluk Egypt and Syria, homoerotic liaisons within the military and administrative elite are documented, often associated with the culture of the ghilmān and the practice of taḥbīb (the art of seducing young boys). Safavid Iran (1501–1723) presents an even more striking case: not only does Persian poetry make love for young boys its quasi-exclusive romantic theme, but houses of male prostitution were legally recognized and paid taxes to the state. This fiscal institutionalization of the sex trade between men shows to what extent theoretical religious condemnation could coexist with a pragmatic economic and social flexibility of astonishing adaptability. The Ottoman Empire, finally, is often cited for its long tradition of köçek, those young cross-dressed dancers who performed at festivals and weddings, and for the relative leniency of the sultans toward homosexual relations, to the point that the criminalization of sodomy was officially abolished only in 1858, under the pressure of modernizing reforms and European influence. The khawal of Egypt, the khanith of Oman, and the hijra of the Indian subcontinent extend, into the contemporary period, this long history of non-binary gender figures whose existence was recognized and often ritually integrated.

It would nevertheless be naive to paint the picture of a golden age of sexual freedom. The tolerance enjoyed by homosexual practices was conditioned by a golden rule: discretion. The jurist Maarten Schild sums it up with precision: in theory, homosexual behavior is severely condemned, but in practice it has always existed and has generally been treated with tolerance as long as it remained confined to the private sphere. The police were not authorized to hunt down sinners; they could intervene only on flagrant offense or public confession. Since the revelation of a grave sin was itself considered a sin, Islamic law emphasized the protection of privacy, which paradoxically amounted to protecting same-sex lovers. The juridical schools diverged radically on punishment: the Hanafi school, the most rationalist, refused to apply the ḥadd (fixed penalty) to liwāṭ, considering it a sin falling under taʿzīr (discretionary punishment left to the judge’s appreciation); the Maliki school, the most rigorist, prescribed death for both partners, married or not, by analogy with zinā. But these theoretical penalties, subject to extremely strict evidentiary requirements (four male witnesses, repeated confession), were in practice rarely applied. The gap between the severity of the fiqh treatises and the reality of the courts, taverns, and harems is one of the most constant features of this history.

The arrival of colonial modernity and the religious reformisms of the nineteenth century gradually broke this precarious balance between norm and practice. The puritanical rediscovery of the texts, the pressure of European powers, and the construction of nation-states led to a much more rigid codification of sexual morals, transforming sins theoretically tolerated in privacy into state crimes punishable by heavy penalties. What the history of Islam and of the countries it governed teaches us is therefore neither absolute license nor continuous repression, but the capacity of complex societies to negotiate, over centuries, a modus vivendi between the normative ideal and the realities of desire. The ghilmān of the poets, the mukhannathūn of the courts, the discreet loves of the harems, and the siḥāq of secluded women are not shameful anomalies to be erased from collective memory; they are the witnesses of a plural, often contradictory, but always profoundly human history.






.

(Ar) مرحبا بكم على هذه المدونة

 . . أهلاً بكم في ملاذي الأدبي يسعدني حقاً أن أرحب بكم هنا. سواءً أكان وصولكم بدافع الفضول، أو مصادفةً من خلال رابط مشترك، أو بدافع حب الكل...